Acid Drainage and Metal Leaching Prediction: Where have we been and Where do we Need to Go - An Historical Perspective

Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Mr Ronald V.Nicholson (EcoMetrix Incorporated)
The effects of mine drainage reportedly date back to Southern Spain almost 3000 years before present and the “poisonous” qualities in mine drainage from ores was made in Agricola’s treatise, De Re Metallica, in 1556. Acidic soils and drainage in North America were observed to be associated with coal mining in the eastern Appalachian region of the USA in the 1940s. After recognizing the cause of acidic conditions as weathering of iron sulphide minerals in disturbed mine materials at the earth surface, efforts were made to develop prediction techniques. The concepts of acid potential (AP) and neutralization potential (NP) were developed in the 1960s with acid base accounting (ABA) introduced in the literature in the early 1970s. Acid conditions at metal mines were “unexpectedly” observed in the 1960s in Canada.

Our current approach to assessing acid generating characteristics and metal leaching are based on a USEPA report authored by Sobek and others in 1978. While the initial purpose of prediction was related to acidic coal spoils and the potential for revegetation, water quality soon became the major focus of attention. While vigorous scientific debate and discussion ensued on the approaches to prediction, the questions gradually turned from “yes or no” to quantifying effects on water quality, including those for neutral drainage conditions. As the science of prediction has matured since the 1970s, there has been a shift to prevention and mitigation strategies for mine materials that represent risks to water quality. And while we have advanced substantially in our understanding of weathering of mine materials and their influence on water quality, there are ongoing debates on methods of interpretation. The challenge of time-dependent processes and the scarcity of full scale “tests” have left many questions yet to answer in our quest to manage risks to the environment from mine wastes. Examples of accomplishments and future challenges will be discussed.
Full Access to Technical Paper
PDF version for $20.00
Other papers from Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Search
Sort By:  Relevance
Showing results 1 - 17
Text
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Patrick Laporte
Year: 2015
Text
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Geneviève Pepin
Year: 2015
Text
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Martine Paradis
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: The nature of the relationships between mines and their local communities continues to evolve over time. This presentation reviews the range in characteristics of what might be termed “mining communities”. These could include those associated with pre-existing Aboriginal and settler communities; those born as a direct result of a mine through its full life cycle; and those at mine sites that are fly-in fly-out operations. It considers the possibility of mine life cycle design and planning...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Malcolm Scoble
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: More and more mines are using double piston pumps for conveying pastes, cakes and slurries.

Stiff pastes are normally used for the stabilization underground. Cement and ashes were added to create a construction material with sufficient strength.

For the tailings and ore transport above ground, slurries are produced and transported over long distances to deposits or to preparation plants.

With this presentation we will show you various job sites around the world where different...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Peter Peschken
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: In the last five years, Agnico Eagle Mines commissioned three new paste backfill plants, Pinos Altos in Mexico, Kittilä in Finland and Goldex in Canada. The first two mines are laterally long with significant horizontal distance requiring elevated pumping pressure to deliver the paste while the third mine is vertical and this time the pressure needs to be controlled to respect the schedule of the pipe. This paper describes the reticulation systems for these three mines and compares the...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Serge Ouellet
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: Many mine operators have some exposure to paste backfill systems and have a general idea of how they work. However, when put in the position of initiating a new backfill project some mine operators and project managers are not aware of the steps involved with the testing, backfill method selection (hydraulic, cemented rockfill, pastefill or hybrid types), concept design, options selection, feasibility design, detailed design, construction, commissioning and training. In addition, mine...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Chris Lee
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: Ferrates are oxy-anions of iron in oxidation states of between two and eight (FeO22- and FeO52-). While several different ferrates have been studied for commercial exploitation, only Ferrate(VI), i.e. (FeO42-) has been utilized for environmental applications. Over 400 published studies have demonstrated the unique treatment capability of Ferrate(VI) for both water and wastewater, as it can simultaneously perform oxidation, and disinfection; and because it is unstable, it is quickly reduced to...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Thomas D. Waite
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: The Diavik Waste Rock Project, which was initiated in 2004, combines laboratory, field and modelling research components to characterize the physicochemical processes occurring in waste rock. Studies have been conducted on samples of waste rock of varying sizes, ranging from a few kilograms in laboratory experiments, 6 tonnes in 2 m scale experiments, 100,000 tonnes in each of three 60 × 60 x 15 m high experimental test piles, to >100 million tonnes in the operational waste-rock pile....
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): David W. Blowes
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: The Meadowbank gold mine of Agnico Eagle is located in the Kivallik region of Nunavut, approximately 110 km by road north of Baker Lake, the nearest community. In operation since early 2010, Meadowbank is currently operating three open pits and is moving over 100,000 tons of rock on a daily basis.

The end of mine operation is currently expected for the end of 2017. Reclamation planning was incorporated early in the mine development planning. Meadowbank mine includes three main waste rock...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Érika Voyer
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: Hecla commissioned their paste plant at Casa Berardi in 2013, however work on the project began much earlier. Over the previous decade, paste fill had been proposed for Casa Berardi through one form or another. More recently (2010), Paterson & Cooke (P&C) conducted a study to trade off several options for paste backfill production and delivery to the future mining areas. This was narrowed to two options involving trucking or pumping paste fill a distance of 4km overland with the initial...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Maureen McGuiness
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: Failures such as the ruptures of the Gullbridge Tailings Impoundment (2012) and the Mount Poulley Tailings Impoundment (2014) can have devastating effects on public safety, the environment or the public’s perception of the mining industry. Davies (2002) estimated that worldwide between 1970 and 2001 there were at least two major impoundment failures annually. The corresponding failure rate is ten times greater than that of water retention dams. It is in the best interests of the mining...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Michael James
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: South America is a diverse region and development of a successful tailings management strategy must consider the unique characteristics of the project and the site. This paper presents some information on the diversity of the challenges that are faced across the continent and shows that there is not a unique strategy that can be applied to all projects. The range of site characteristics and project considerations include:
• Annual rainfall of 1 mm in the Atacama Desert to 5000 mm in...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Terry Eldridge
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: Canada's Oil Sands Innovation Alliance has published a Technical Guide for Fluid Fine Tailings Management (TGFFTM). The key issue identified for the management of fluid fine tailings (FFT) during the operation of oil sands mines centres on the creation of dry landscapes and sustainable terrains for mine reclamation. The current volume of legacy mature fine tailings (MFT) in above grade containment dams exceeds 850 million m³. The TGFFTM specifically states, “the methods for transformation of...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Ward G. Wilson
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: Acidic mine drainage (AMD) is an environmental pollutant that impairs water resources in mining regions throughout the world. Where such treatment is required legally, treatment must be efficient and continuous. Treatment methods are commonly divided into either “active” or “passive.” Active chemical treatment is often an expensive, long term liability. During the past 35 years, a variety of passive treatment systems have been developed that take advantage of naturally occurring chemical and...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Jeff Skousen
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: Predictions usually fail because of human arrogance and ignorance. We think we know things we don’t know and physical reality is more complex than our simple models can portray. We cannot succeed by disregarding human failures. Humidity-cell tests (HCTs) were designed to mimic weathering reactions in the laboratory for remediation planning. Few really questioned whether such tests were meaningful when applied to a large-scale mine waste site. What should be the optimal length of time to do...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): D. Kirk Nordstrom
Year: 2015
Text
Summary: The effects of mine drainage reportedly date back to Southern Spain almost 3000 years before present and the “poisonous” qualities in mine drainage from ores was made in Agricola’s treatise, De Re Metallica, in 1556. Acidic soils and drainage in North America were observed to be associated with coal mining in the eastern Appalachian region of the USA in the 1940s. After recognizing the cause of acidic conditions as weathering of iron sulphide minerals in disturbed mine materials at the earth...
Proceedings: Symposium 2015 Rouyn-Noranda
Author(s): Ronald V. Nicholson
Year: 2015
Powered by Coveo Enterprise Search